Driven by the Feelings You Choose: Why Feelings Aren’t Facts (and Aren’t Lies, Either)
Happy. Bored. Numb. Excited. Mad. Funny. Confused. Playful. Disappointed. Rejected. Loved. Weary. Pumped. Content. Alone. Concerned. Hopeful. Ashamed. Powerful. Afraid.
Feelings. They ebb and flow, and can change in a heartbeat. They are not the truth, but they seem to wield the power of truth, even when they contradict each other.
And there are two camps lined up to tell you what to do with them. Both are half wrong.
Camp one says, “Your feelings are valid.” Full stop. Honor them, trust them, follow them wherever they go.
Camp two, usually standing in the church foyer, says, “Feelings aren’t facts.” Which, in practice, tends to mean: stop having them. Especially the inconvenient ones. And get back in line.
Here’s what neither camp tells you:
Most of what you’re calling a feeling isn’t a feeling at all. It’s a conclusion.
Feelings Are Downstream
Here’s what actually happens, usually in less than a second.
Something happens. You see it, hear it, notice it. Then, before you’ve even clocked it, you make a meaning out of it. You attribute a motive.
She didn’t text back because she’s annoyed with me. He went quiet because I said too much. God feels silent because I’ve disappointed Him.
That meaning becomes the perception. The perception fuels the feeling. And the feeling grabs the steering wheel.
What happened → the meaning I made → the motive I assigned → what I feel → what I do.
By the time you feel rejected, you’ve already decided you were rejected. The feeling is just the receipt.
So yes, your feelings are valid. They’re real. You’re really having them. But they can be real AND built on a faulty conclusion. Valid and accurate are not the same word.
Feelings are information. Anger, for one, tells you what matters, because if it didn’t matter, you wouldn’t be angry. But information about what matters isn’t the same as information about what happened.
Most of the time we let these feelings drive our behavior like mindless fools. Not because we’re foolish, but because nobody ever showed us the conclusion hiding underneath.
You Were Made to Make Meaning
This part isn’t a flaw. You were created to make meaning. To understand, to grow, to act. The very first job God handed a human being was to look at what was in front of him and name it (Genesis 2:19).
The problem isn’t that you make meaning. It’s the lens you’re making it through.
The Lens That Kept You Safe
If you’ve lived for years (five, maybe twenty) in a relationship where the ground could shift without warning, your brain did something smart. It learned to scan. To read the mood from the sound of the garage door. To assume danger first, because assuming safety had a cost.
That isn’t paranoia. That’s training. And in that house, it was often right.
But a lens trained for danger doesn’t switch off at the property line. It comes with you. To the friend who hasn’t texted back. To the pastor who is actually safe. To the compliment. To the good day. To your own kid’s quiet. To God.
And it brings two accomplices.
Confirmation bias. Once your brain has a theory, it goes looking for evidence, and it’s very good at finding it. Whatever fits gets filed. Whatever doesn’t gets dismissed as a fluke.
Pain avoidance. If you expect the worst, you can’t be blindsided. Hope feels risky. Hope is how you got hurt last time. So the good gets held at arm’s length, not because you can’t see it, but because believing it feels like setting yourself up.
Put those together and something sneaky happens. You start compounding your own pain. Not because the bad isn’t real. It is. But because the good is real too, and you’ve stopped letting it count.
Your radar isn’t broken. It’s just been tuned to one station for so long, you’ve forgotten there’s anything playing on the others.
Let Me Be Very Clear About What This Is NOT
This is not me telling you to give him the benefit of the doubt.
If you’ve lived with coercive control, you’ve probably been handed a version of this already. “Assume the best.” “You’re reading into it.” “Maybe he didn’t mean it that way.”
That’s not discernment. That’s gaslighting with a Bible verse attached.
A pattern is evidence. Years of the same behavior, the same aftermath, the same apology that changes nothing: that’s data, and you do not have to reinterpret it into something nicer. Real change has markers, and your hope isn’t one of them.
What I’m talking about is the spillover. The places where the lens built for him has started reading everything and everyone else the same way. Including you. Including God.
Discernment isn’t assuming the worst. It isn’t assuming the best, either. Discernment is looking at what’s actually there. ALL of it.
Take Every Thought Captive (Actually)
“Take every thought captive” (2 Corinthians 10:5) has been used on a lot of women to mean: stuff it. Don’t feel that. Submit the thought and move along.
But you don’t take a prisoner captive by pretending he isn’t in the room. You take him captive so you can question him.
That’s what this is. Not suppressing the thought. Interrogating it.
And Philippians 4:8, “whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely… think about such things,” has been handed to you as only think happy thoughts.
Read it again. The list starts with TRUE. Not pleasant. Not positive. True. And then it says the lovely things are true, too. Don’t leave them out.
Three Assessments to Challenge the Story
Grab a notebook for these. Or, if you’d like guided pages built for exactly this kind of work, my journal Tools for Healing walks you through it.
Assessment 1: Split the Fact from the Story
Pick one moment from this week that’s still sitting heavy. Write it out in four lines:
- What happened? Only what a camera could have recorded. No adjectives.
- What meaning did I make of it?
- What motive did I assign?
- What did I feel?
Picture it: you invite a friend to dinner. Two days, no response.
- What happened: I sent a text Tuesday. No reply as of Thursday.
- Meaning: She doesn’t want to come.
- Motive: She’s pulling away. People are picking sides since the separation.
- Feeling: Alone. A little humiliated.
Now look at line one. It’s one sentence. Everything after it, you supplied. That doesn’t make it wrong. It makes it worth checking.
Assessment 2: The Meaning Audit
Take the meaning from line two and run it through these.
- Is it true? Not does it feel true. Is it?
- How do I know? What’s my actual evidence? Is it this person’s pattern, or someone else’s pattern wearing this person’s face?
- What else could also be true? Not Also. Name at least two. (She’s slammed at work. She saw it while driving and forgot. She wants to come and is figuring out childcare.)
- What does believing this make me do? Withdraw? Over-explain? Reject her first so she can’t reject me?
- What would I do differently if I held it loosely? Not dropped. Just loosely.
- So what’s mine to choose? Not what should I stop feeling, but what do I want to do with this data? (Send one more text. Or let it be, and go to dinner anyway.)
Notice the last question doesn’t ask you to talk yourself out of anything. You’re not suppressing the feeling. You’re using it as a data point to choose your next move, a decision about you, not a verdict about her.
Assessment 3: The Overlooked-Good Inventory
At the end of the day, three questions:
- What went right today that I walked right past?
- Who showed up, even a little, that I didn’t let count?
- Where did I see God’s fingerprints and talk myself out of it?
This isn’t gratitude journaling as pretend-it’s-fine. It’s evidence-gathering. Confirmation bias works in both directions, so give it the other half of the data.
You’ve become an excellent detective of danger. Now get just as good at detecting the good.
Carry Both
You don’t deny the bad. It’s still there; you can’t rid your life of it. But be curious about what else is “there” as well. Maybe there’s another way to see the situation. Maybe it means something different than you thought. Maybe it’s not about you at all, but about them.
You have the capacity to carry both grief and joy at the same time, and to choose which one gets the loudest vote in how you live today. Grief doesn’t cancel the joy. The joy doesn’t betray the grief.
You get to choose the meaning you make. Whatever you choose will fuel the feelings you feel loudest, and you’ll act on those feelings as if they’re the truth. So choose on purpose.
Discernment Is a Muscle
If your perception has been worked over for years, you don’t get it back by being told to trust your gut. You get it back by practicing, one small, checked conclusion at a time.
We can train ourselves to perceive more critically, which strengthens our capacity to trust our own gut. That means processing what we see thoughtfully and with curiosity, so we don’t get trapped in nonsensical loops built on habitual, shallow responses.
And when the old instrument starts shouting (when guilt shows up like a compass somebody else re-magnetized), you don’t have to obey it, and you don’t have to shame it. You check it. Then you stand firm in what you know.
So Here’s the Deal…
You’re not crazy for feeling what you feel. You’re also not obligated to obey it.
The danger you learned to see was real. The good you’ve learned to step over is real, too. And a woman who can see both is a woman nobody gets to steer anymore. Not him, not the foyer, and not the old lens.
God is not only in the hard chapters of your story. He’s in the good you’ve been trained to walk past. Let it count.
Next Steps
- Tools for Healing: my guided journal for women healing from emotional and narcissistic abuse. Nine chapters and 36 questions, rooted in faith and written to be lived with slowly. A private place to separate what happened from the story you’ve been carrying. Instant download.
- Identity Recovery Groups: a small group of women who will help you check the story, without telling you to assume the best about the person who hurt you.
- One-to-one coaching with me or Identity Recovery Coach Lauren Rose, when you need someone to think out loud with: booking portal.
Find yourself. Keep yourself.
About the author. Sharmen Elaine Kimbrough is an identity strategist and the founder of LiveFound, Inc. She holds a Master’s degree in professional counseling and spent more than ten years developing and leading the women’s programs at the Marriage Recovery Center. She writes for women recovering a self after emotional abuse, coercive control, and spiritual bypassing. More about Sharmen →





